Exodus 11:3
Did Moses inappropriately call himself great in Exodus 11:3?
It is objected that people are usually spoken of as great only after their death, and Moses would hardly have made a comment of this nature about himself. Both aspects of this objection involve modern notions of humility that do not apply to the Ancient Near East. In the literature of that time rulers and significant people are regularly referred to in like manner during their lifetimes, even according to their own writings. Frankness and honesty about one's own abilities and power were not out of order.
Would Moses call himself "great" in Exodus 11:3?
Exodus 11:3 states:
> ...Moreover the man Moses was very great in the land of Egypt...
Some object that people are usually spoken of as great only after their death, and that Moses would hardly have made a comment of this nature about himself. This objection relies on modern notions of humility that do not apply to the Ancient Near East.
In the literature of that time, rulers and significant people are regularly referred to in like manner during their lifetimes, even according to their own writings. Frankness and honesty about one's own abilities and power were not out of order.
The Jewish historian Josephus notes that Moses held a high position in Egypt prior to his departure to the wilderness. Exodus 11:3 is in line with this and stresses Moses' prominence in the land, a convention similar to how modern people respectfully refer to high-ranking officials.
Exodus 11:3 - How could Moses have written these words of self-praise?
Expanded from Num. 12:3:
Numbers 12:3—How can this statement have been written by Moses?
Problem: Numbers 12:3 says, “Now the man Moses was very humble, more than all men who were on the face of the earth.” The conservative view of the Pentateuch is that Moses was the author of these five books. But, how could Moses make such a statement about himself if he were really humble?
Solution: Of course, no one would claim that Jesus was being boastful or prideful by saying “I am meek and lowly in heart” (Matt. 11:29, kjv). Jesus was simply stating the facts. Likewise, Moses is not boasting or being prideful about his humility. Rather, he was simply stating a fact which was crucial for understanding the significance of the events he was reporting.
Earlier in chapter 11, after the Spirit of the Lord came upon Eldad and Medad so that they began to prophesy, Joshua approached Moses and said, “Moses my lord, forbid them!” (Num. 11:28) Moses’ response is a perfect illustration of the humility that 12:3 describes: “Are you zealous for my sake? Oh, that all the Lord’s people were prophets and that the Lord would put His Spirit upon them!” (Num. 11:29) Moses exhibited the character of a humble man who was not interested in his own glory, but only in the glory of the Lord.
When Moses is confronted by Miriam and Aaron in 12:1, Moses did not respond in his own defense. A humble person does not usually rise to his own defense. Why didn’t Moses just tell them? Why didn’t he set them straight? Why did God have to speak to Miriam and Aaron in Moses’ behalf? The explanation is found in 12:3. Moses was not out for his own glorification. If Moses had responded in his own defense, he would have been justifying their complaints against him. But, Moses was not the leader of the people because of any ambition on his own part, or any self-confidence or self-assertive ladder climbing. He was appointed by God. So verse 12:3 is a vindication of Moses’ character. It is not a statement of boastful pride. It is simply a statement of fact.