Surah 8

Surah 8:1

"They ask you about the spoils. Say: ‘The spoils (belong) to God and the messenger. So guard (yourselves) against God, and set right what is between you. Obey God and His messenger, if you are believers.’"

This sūra signals immediately that it is connected with conflict: “The spoils (belong) to Allah and the messenger.” Though subsequent verses do not provide a context for the action, the sūra explicitly mentions battle (
qitāl
; v. 16), war (
ḥarb
; v. 57), fighting (
qātala
; v. 39, 64), killing (
qatala
; v. 17, 30), holding captives (vv. 67, 70), military advance (
zaḥf
, v. 15), and other vocabulary of armed engagement.
The sūra provides instruction and encouragement to the “believers” for their encounter with the enemy. Both Allah and “the messenger” are to be obeyed in the heat of battle. Not only are the unbelievers to be attacked, but the believers themselves are repeatedly threatened in order to motivate them to advance to the front lines.
A number of verses in this sūra offer a strong theological interpretation of the conflict. Here Allah promises, plans, and guides the battle, sends his angels to back the believers, and himself kills the enemy (v. 17). Though the sūra names no persons or places, tradition associates it with a famous military engagement in the Muslim story of Islamic origins – the “battle of Badr” (
Sīra
, 321–27,
Raids
, 66–70).

- from The Quran with Christian Commentary: A Guide to Understanding the Scripture of Islam

8.1 – The spoils (belong) to God and the messenger
The abrupt change of content and tone from Sūra 7 to Sūra 8 is striking. Here suddenly the Quran tells about spoils of battle, or war loot ( anfāl , the sūra’s title). This kind of change is a characteristic of the Quran that has raised questions for many readers. On the face of it, these are two different kinds of writing.
From the beginning of Sūra 8, the messenger has a very different profile from the messenger described in the preceding two sūras (6 and 7). In Sūra 7, the messenger is “only a warner” (7:188). His task there is to recite the signs of Allah and to urge people to respond appropriately to Allah.
Muslim scholars have accounted for the differences between sūras 6 and 7 on the one hand, and sūras 8 and 9 on the other, by asserting that they belong to different periods in the life of Muhammad. They claim that the messenger of Islam recited sūras 6 and 7 while in Mecca, then recited sūras 8 and 9 later in Medina, according to the traditional story. The Quran itself does not indicate the times or places of these recitations. Some scholars suggest that the chronology was rather imposed from outside of the Quran – especially from Muslim stories about Islamic origins written in the second and third centuries of Islam.
Islamic Studies scholar David Marshall makes the case that Sūra 8 represents a transition in the Quran from the understanding that Allah alone punishes unbelievers to the idea that Allah uses “believers” to punish unbelievers by defeating them militarily in this world.

- from The Quran with Christian Commentary: A Guide to Understanding the Scripture of Islam

8.1 – Obey Allah and His messenger, if you are believers
The command to obey both Allah and “His messenger” appears more frequently in Sūra 8 than in any other sūra (also vv. 20, 46; cf. v. 24). Sūra 8 also associates the messenger with Allah for spoils of war (vv. 1, 41), in opposition (v. 13), and in betrayal (v. 27), compared with only one occurrence of such pairing in the preceding two sūras (7.158).
These commands to obey both Allah and his messenger became very important in the writings of the influential Muslim jurist al-Shāfi‘ī (d. 820), who insisted that they gave divine authority to the sayings (“hadith”) attributed to Muhammad. See the summary and analysis of these commands at 64.12.

- from The Quran with Christian Commentary: A Guide to Understanding the Scripture of Islam